ABSTRACT

The medical humanities have moved into an exciting era of interdisciplinary cross-currents, exchanges and debates that embrace the academic study of medical culture, competing notions of health and illness, public engagement with medicine, contemporary arts taking medical themes as a stimulus for provocative work, and new readings of the more traditional ‘primal scene’ of the doctor-patient relationship. This magisterial new Handbook offers a comprehensive and cutting-edge overview of the state of the medical humanities globally, showing how clinically-oriented medical humanities, the critical study of medicine as a global historical and cultural phenomenon, and medicine as a force for cultural change can intersect and inform each other.

Comprised of seven parts, this Handbook looks at the medical humanities as:

  • a network and system
  • therapeutic
  • provocation
  • forms of resistance
  • a way of reconceptualising the medical curriculum
  • concerned with performance and narrative
  • mediated by artists as diagnosticians of culture and public engagement

Further developing our sense of what medical humanities can and does encompass, the Routledge Handbook of the Medical Humanities describes how the medical humanities can be put to work in and out of clinical settings, acting as a point of resistance, redistributing medicine’s capital amongst its stakeholders, embracing the complexity of medical instances, shaping medical education, promoting interdisciplinary understandings and recognising an identity for the medical humanities as a network effect. It pays attention to how the arts, humanities and liberal social sciences provide frames of reference that encourage imaginatively about typical clinical issues, such as diagnostic thinking and the consultation, and about wider issues such as the loose way in which descriptors such as ‘health’, ‘wellbeing’, ‘illness’, ‘pathology’ are used, carrying value judgements. At one and the same time, it explores how the clinical encounter, the education of doctors including identity constructions, and the study of medical cultures, could be interlinked for interdisciplinary inquiry.

This book is an essential read for all students, scholars and practitioners with an interest in the medical humanities.

chapter |28 pages

Introduction

The medical humanities: a mixed weather front on a global scale
ByAlan Bleakley

part I|43 pages

Medical humanities as networks, systems and translations

chapter 1|3 pages

A dose of empathy from my Syrian doctor

ByRandi Davenport

chapter 2|7 pages

The cultural crossings of care

A call for translational medical humanities
ByJulia Kristeva, Marie Rose Moro, John Ødemark, Eivind Engebretsen

chapter 3|14 pages

Medical work in transition

Towards collaborative and transformative expertise
ByYrjö Engeström

chapter 4|17 pages

Health, health care, and health education

Problems, paradigms, and patterns
ByStewart Mennin, Glenda Eoyang, Mary Nations

part II|54 pages

Democratising medicine

chapter 5|8 pages

The state of the union

Rigour and responsibility in US health humanities
ByTherese Jones, Delese Wear

chapter 6|14 pages

The cutting edge

Health humanities for equity and social justice
ByArno K. Kumagai, Thirusha Naidu

chapter 7|8 pages

Geography as engaged medical-health-humanities

ByCourtney Donovan, Sarah de Leeuw

chapter 8|9 pages

Challenging heteronormativity in medicine

ByWilliam J. Robertson

chapter 9|9 pages

Medical Nemesis 40 years on

The enduring legacy of Ivan Illich
BySeamus O’Mahony

chapter 10|4 pages

Hospitaland

ByJefferson Wong

part III|75 pages

Medicine’s metaphors and rhetoric

chapter 11|7 pages

Don’t breathe a word

A psychoanalysis of medicine’s inflations
ByAlan Bleakley

chapter 12|8 pages

Metaphor as art

A thought experiment
ByAnita Wohlmann

chapter 13|11 pages

The practice of metaphor

ByShane Neilson

chapter 14|8 pages

Medical slang

Symptom or solution?
ByNicole M. Piemonte

chapter 15|13 pages

Ageism and rhetoric

ByJudy Z. Segal

chapter 16|9 pages

The rhetorical possibilities of a multi-metaphorical view of clinical supervision

ByLorelei Lingard, Mark Goldszmidt

chapter 17|7 pages

The chaotic narratives of anti-vaccination

ByKatherine Shwetz

chapter 18|10 pages

Thought curfew

Empathy’s endgame?
ByDavid Cotterrell

part IV|64 pages

Medicine as performance and public engagement

chapter 19|15 pages

The performing arts in medicine and medical education

ByClaire Hooker, James Dalton

chapter 20|14 pages

A manifesto for artists’ books and the medical humanities

ByStella Bolaki

chapter 21|8 pages

Grasping emergency care through pop culture

The truths and lies of film, television and other video-based media
ByHenry A. Curtis

chapter 22|8 pages

Who is the audience for the medical/health humanities?

BySuzy Willson, Pamela Brett-Maclean, Bella Eacott

chapter 23|7 pages

Desire imagination action

Theatre of the Oppressed in medical education
ByRavi Ramaswamy, Radha Ramaswamy

chapter 24|7 pages

Zombie sickness

Contagious ideas in performance
ByMartin O’Brien, Gianna Bouchard

chapter 25|3 pages

The masks of uncertainty

ByCara Martin

part V|51 pages

Embodiment and disembodiment

chapter 26|3 pages

Nobody’s Home

BySusan Bleakley

chapter 27|10 pages

Ecstasy

ByAlphonso Lingis

chapter 28|8 pages

Relationships that matter

Embodying absent kinships in the Japanese child welfare system
ByKathryn E. Goldfarb

chapter 29|10 pages

Still Alice?

Ethical aspects of conceptualising selfhood in dementia
ByLisa Folkmarson Käll, Kristin Zeiler

chapter 30|9 pages

Body Maps

Reframing embodied experiences through ethnography and art
ByCari Costanzo

chapter 31|9 pages

Perspectives on olfaction in medical culture

ByCrispian Neill

part VI|61 pages

The medical humanities in medical education

chapter 32|11 pages

The ‘awe-full’ fascination of pathology

ByQuentin Eichbaum, Leonard White, Gwinyai Masukume, Gil Pena

chapter 33|12 pages

Biomedical ethics and the medical humanities

Sensing the aesthetic
ByPaul Macneill

chapter 34|10 pages

Medical humanities online

Experiences from South Africa
BySteve Reid, Susan Levine

chapter 35|10 pages

‘Your effort was great/you carried me nine months’

The birth of medical humanities in Ethiopia
ByIan Fussell, Robert Marshall

chapter 36|16 pages

Medical humanities in Canadian medical schools

Progress, challenges and opportunities
ByAllan Peterkin, Natalie Beausoleil, Monica Kidd, Bahar Orang, Hesam Noroozi, Pamela Brett-Maclean

part VII|42 pages

The patient will see you now

chapter 37|10 pages

Can we make empathy more intelligent? try social empathy!

ByCaroline Wellbery

chapter 38|8 pages

A letter from Marijke Boucherie to Alan Bleakley

ByMarijke Boucherie

chapter 39|9 pages

Health humanities

A democratising future beyond medical humanities
ByPaul Crawford, Brian Brown

chapter 40|9 pages

Doctors need safe confessional and cathartic spaces

What we learned from the research project ‘People Talking: Digital Dialogues for Mutual Recovery’
ByJon Allard, Michael Wilson, Alan Bleakley

chapter 41|4 pages

All thanks to the words of a stranger

An homage to the UK’s National Health Service
BySophie Holloway

part VIII|13 pages

Overview

chapter 42|11 pages

Negotiating research in the medical humanities

ByMaria Athina (Tina) Martimianakis, Cynthia R. Whitehead, Ayelet Kuper